(Be aware this lecture may take some time to load due to embedded windows onto external resources. Since the equations in this lecture are the last to load, they will not look correct until loading has finished. Depending on your internet connection speed this may take up to a minute.)
Here you can see an animation of the three failure modes for a timber beam that we will be checking this semester, shear, bending, and deflection.
Scroll down to see all three beam failure modes.
Don't know and want to know why the shear stress failure presents as a horizontal crack, read this.
(Click the blue down arrow to hear a brief description of the failure mode we won't be looking at.)
When a timber beam is loaded in a way such that the compression side of the beam in bending is on the opposite side from the loading, i.e. wind uplift, then we need to check beam stability. In a steel beam this is know as lateral torsional buckling. In timber we check this with the $C_L$ adjustment factor.
Because we are always loading the beams, in this course, on the same side as the compression, we will not be using $C_L$. If you want to learn about it I suggest reading through the beam examples in the "Structural Wood Design Solved Example Problems" of your wood design package.
The process of analyzing a timber beam goes like this.
In hand solution we will typically go back and forth between steps 3 and 4 looking at the the allowable and actual values for bending, shear, and deflection rather than finding all of the allowable vales then all of the actual values. In the design process we can stop as soon as we find a failure mode rather than doing additional work.
You should be aware that in this course I will want you to solve all the values regardless if you find a failure mode early on.
Let's work through an example to see the whole process.
Typical Problem Statement:
A 2x10 Douglas Fir-South Grade No.2 beam is used as a floor joist. The joists span are 10'-6", and they are spaced 16" on center. Wet service conditions prevail. The deflection limits are L/360 for live load and L/240 for total load. (This comes from Chapter 16 of the Florida Building Code (FBC).) The floor is subjected to a uniform dead load of 15 psf and live load of 75 psf.
Values from problem statement:
$\text{Span: }$
$\text{Grade: No.2}$
$\text{Size: 2x10}$
$\text{Spacing: }$
$\text{Live Load: }$
$\text{Dead Load: }$
$\text{Deflection Limits: }$
Note about this course:
To be clear, for simplicity reasons, I generally will give you a deflection limit to use so you will not have to look it up. I often will give you a deflection limit that is more conservative than you you will find in the table but in practice you should look at the construction specifications for the limits you need to use.
(Click on the blue down arrow to see the Florida Building Code Deflection Limits table and notes.)
Table 1604.3 Notes:
a. For structural roofing and siding made of formed metal sheets, the total load deflection shall not exceed l/60. For secondary roof structural members supporting formed metal roofing, the live load deflection shall not exceed l/150. For secondary wall members supporting formed metal siding, the design wind load deflection shall not exceed l/90. For roofs, this exception only applies when the metal sheets have no roof covering.
b. Interior partitions not exceeding 6 feet in height and flexible, folding and portable partitions are not governed by the provisions of this section. The deflection criterion for interior partitions is based on the horizontal load defined in Section 1607.13.
c. See Section 2403 for glass supports.
d. For wood structural members having a moisture content of less than 16 percent at time of installation and used under dry conditions, the deflection resulting from L + 0.5 D is permitted to be substituted for the deflection resulting from L + D.
e. The above deflections do not ensure against ponding. Roofs that do not have sufficient slope or camber to assure adequate drainage shall be investigated for ponding. See Section 1611 for rain and ponding requirements and Section 1503.4 for roof drainage requirements.
f. The wind load is permitted to be taken as 0.42 times the "component and cladding" loads for the purpose of determining deflection limits herein.
g. For steel structural members, the dead load shall be taken as zero.
h. For aluminum structural members or aluminum panels used in skylights and sloped glazing framing, roofs or walls of sunroom additions or patio covers, not supporting edge of glass or aluminum sandwich panels, the total load deflection shall not exceed l/60. For continuous aluminum structural members supporting edge of glass, the total load deflection shall not exceed l/175 for each glass lite or l/60 for the entire length of the member, whichever is more stringent. For aluminum sandwich panels used in roofs or walls of sunroom additions or patio covers, the total load deflection shall not exceed l/120.
i. For cantilever members, l shall be taken as twice the length of the cantilever.
j. Screen surfaces shall be permitted to include a maximum of 25% solid flexible finishes.
Because I did not indicate otherwise in the problem statement we will assume that this is a floor subject to construction loading. This means that my load duration factor, $C_D = 1.25$. Note that I will indicate what load duration factor to use by saying "wind loading" $(C_D= 1.6)$, "design for multiple reuses" or "assume long term load duration" $(C_D = 1.0)$.
From Table 1B in the Supplement we find:
Because the problem statement did not have any indication that the beam was in the weak orientation, or "on the flat", we will assume that it is in the strong orientation. This means that the bending is occurring about the X-X axis.
In equations I will drop the xx (or yy) subscript, for convenience, making these values $S$ and $I$. You should also note that if you know the values for $b$ and $d$ you can easily calculate the values for $A$, $S$ and $I$ because all sawn lumber timber sections are rectangular.
$$A = b \times d$$$$S = \frac{1}{6}\times b \times d^2$$$$I = \frac{1}{12}\times b \times d^3$$(Of course if the beam is on the flat the values for $b$ and $d$ switch in these equations.)
In summary the beam geometric values are:
beam.geometry_latex
We know from the problem statement that:
But they are not in the form we can use them in our beam equations. Beams are analyzed using line loads not pressure. We need to use the tributary width to convert these loads to line loads.
The tributary width is half the distance from one beam to the next on both sides. To make sense of this let's make the variable for the spacing from one beam to the next to be lower case $s$.
$W_{trib} = \frac{1}{2} \times s + \frac{1}{2} \times s = s$
In our case the spacing is $16"$, so $W_{trib} = 16"$.
The variable for line loads is usually $w$, and we find $w$ by multiplying the pressure by the tributary width.
(Click the blue down arrow to see the line load calculations.)
For the Live Load:
and for the Dead Load:
The total line load $w$ is just the super position of the two (just add them):
$$w = w_{dead} + w_{live}$$$$w = 20 plf + 100 plf$$$$w = 120 plf$$We know that the species of lumber of the beam is Douglas Fir-South and the grade is No.2. We also know that the beam is $2"$ thick so what table do you think we should look in?
(Click the light blue down arrow to find out what table we need to use.)
Well the beam is $2"$ thick, so we don't use Table 4D; it is for members that are $5" \times 5"$ or larger.
The species is not Southern Pine, so we don't use Table 4B.
That means we need to look up the unmodified allowable stresses in Table 4A of the Supplement.
On page 34 of the in the Supplement we find that,
beam.unmodified_stresses_latex
For timber beams under a uniform line loading we generally check check bending first since it is the most likely failure mode. We will then check shear and finally deflection.
In this course we are generally only concerned with one load combination; that is the construction total load. We always will use it for bending and shear and most of the time we will use it for deflection as well. Since this is or first example it is a more complete example, e.g. we will be checking deflections for the Live Load and the Total Load.
The total uniform line load of our beam $w=120plf$. For a beam with a uniform line load, the value of the bending moment can be found with the following equation.
$$\text{Moment} = \frac{\text{Line Load} \times (\text{Beam Span (or Length)})^2}{8}$$$$M = \frac{w L^2}{8}$$$$M = \frac{120 plf \times (10.5 ft)^2}{8}$$so,
beam.M_latex #in foot pounds
The actual stresses are denoted using lower case $f$ instead of the upper case $F$ for the allowable stresses. The allowable bending stress is $F_b'$ so our actual bending stress is $f_b$. You may recall from your previous classes that the bending moment,
$\text{Moment} = \text{Maximum Bending Stress} \times \text{Section Modulus}$
or,
$M = f_b \times S$
so,
$f_b = \frac{M}{S}$
where $f_b$ is the stress at the extreme fibers of the top and bottom surfaces.
You may have also seen the relationship written as $\sigma = \frac{M \times c}{I}$ but $S = \frac{I}{c}$.
(Click the blue down arrow to see our beam's actual bending stress.)
beam.f_b_latex
(Note that this is equation 3.3-1 on page 15 in the 2015 Timber NDS.)
We need to know what adjustment factors we have to apply to $F_b$ to get the allowable bending stress. These are listed in the NDS Table 4.3.1. For bending we have: $C_D$, $C_M$, $C_t$, $C_L$, $C_F$, $C_{fu}$, $C_i$, and $C_r$. Lets look at each of them in turn.
$C_D = 1.25$ as was discussed previously because this problem is for construction loading on a temporary structure.
$C_M$ is found at the from of the tables where we found $F_b$. In this case we used Table 4A and on page 32 we see that for a beam loaded in wet service conditions we have a $C_M =0.85$. But there is the footnote *. Based on the footnote we need to check to see if $F_b \times C_F$ is less than 1,150 psi.
$C_F$ is found on the same page (since this is not Southern Pine). We look at the rows with the white background because the grade is No.2; the beam is nominally 10" wide, and 2" thick so $C_F = 1.1$
$F_b \times C_F = 850 psi \times 1.1 = 935 psi$ which is less than 1,150 psi therefore $C_M = 1.0$.
Whenever one of the adjustment factors does not apply, then the value you use for it is always one. In a hand solution you can indicate that the adjustment factor does not apply by drawing a slash through it in the symbolic form of the equation, or if it is one, (look at the example hand solution to see this).
$C_t$ is the adjustment factor for high temperature exposure. You can look that up in Table 2.3.3 of the Timber NDS but in this course none of the timber members will be exposed to high temperatures, so $C_t = 1$.
$C_L$ is used only when we have a wind uplift condition in a roof, so... not in this course and $C_L = 1$
$C_{fu}$ is for flat use. This is on the same page as $C_M$ but our beam is loaded in the strong direction so $C_{fu}=1$.
$C_r$ is the repetitive member factor. This is also on the same page as $C_M$ and by reading the description of when it is applied we see that our beam is less than 24" on center, and is connected by a floor to 3 or more members. (If it is part of a floor that is of any usable size this is always true.) Since we have met the usage criteria then $C_r = 1.15$.
(Click the blue down arrow to see the Allowable Stress calculations.)
beam.F_b_latex #(allowable)
Timber/Moisture.py:-1: UserWarning: Warning: Becuase F_b*C_F<=1150 then C_M = 1 for F_b (see note)
$F_b' = 1344 psi \geq f_b = 928 psi \text{ so this beam is GOOD in bending.}$
(You may notice that there is the warning message alerting us to the change in the value of $C_M$. This is something that I display automatically to check homework solutions.)
For a beam under a uniformly distrubuted line load the maximum shear in the beam can be found using the following equation.
$$\text{Shear} = \frac{\text{Line Load} \times \text{Beam Span (or Length)}}{2}$$$$V = \frac{w L}{2}$$Recall that $w=120plf$ and $L = 10.5 ft$.
$$V = \frac{120 plf \times 10.5 ft}{2}$$so
beam.V_latex # in pounds
You might remember from previous classes that the maximum shear stress is,
$\text{Shear Stress} = \frac{3}{2} \times \frac{\text{Shear}}{\text{Cross Sectional Area}}$
$\text{Shear Stress} = \frac{3}{2} \frac{V}{A}$
(If not you can look at this to review.)
Remember that in Timber we use a lower case $f$ to indicate actual stress. That means for our beam the shear stress is,
beam.f_v_latex
(Note that this is equation 3.4-2 in the Timber NDS.)
Again we refer to Table 4.3.1 to determine the adjustment factors we need to apply to $F_v$ to find the allowable shear stress $F_v'$.
We find that we need $C_D$, $C_M$, $C_t$, and $C_i$.
$C_D = 1.25$ from before.
$C_M$ is found from the adjustment values for Table 4A on page 32 of the Supplement. Since our beam is being used in wet service conditions, $C_M = 0.97$.
$C_t = 1$ for the same reason we previously covered in bending.
$C_i$, the incising factor, is found on the same page as Table 4.3.1 of the Timber NDS. Suffice it to say that $C_i$ is only used if the beam has been incised for pressure treating. This is not typical and none of the beams in this course will be incised in any way; so $C_i =1$ always.
Our beam's allowable shear stress $(F_v')$ is,
beam.F_v_latex
$F_v' = 218.2 psi \geq f_v = 68.11 psi \text{ so this beam is GOOD in shear.}$
(Look at the slide below to see why $C_M$ is different from before.)
Reading the $C_M$ table is often confusing for students initially. When you are looking in the Supplement to determine $C_M$ you need to realize that the table for $C_M$ is really a table. It is a table with just one row of values, but it is really a table. Each of the values in that single row are for the specific term listed at the top of their respective column.
For example, when you look at the table you can see that the first column is for $F_b$ and the value is 0.85*. However the value under $F_v$ is 0.97. When calculating the prime value like $F_b'$, $F_v'$, or for any term you will need to use the value for $C_M$ that is listed under that particular term.
You will also notice that there are asterisks next to two values. These values are conditionally based on the notes listed below the table. For the value for $C_M$ when working with $F_b$ if $F_b \times C_F \le 1,150 psi$ then $C_M \neq 0.85$ but rather $C_M = 1.0$.
There is a similar condition for $F_c$ but we are not going to cover that until we get into columns.
Deflection analysis is done slightly differently from the rest of allowable stress design. In all of the other checks we are applying the adjustment factors to the allowable stress. When checking deflection we are modifying the actual deflection by adjusting the allowable Young's modulus (or elastic modulus).
Part of the reason for this is that the allowable deflection is specified by the use case and is not an intrinsic property of a beam.
Anyway, the adjustment factors for the Young's modulus listed in Table 4.3.1 of the Timber NDS are, $C_M$, $C_t$, and $C_i$.
You will notice that $C_D$ is not listed. The load duration does not have an effect on the initial deflection of a beam. The effect of long term loading to a beam's deflection is called creep and is discussed in section 3.5.2 of the NDS but we do not need to concern ourselves with this.
$C_M$ is found at the beginning of Table 4A (on page 32) of the Supplement and since our beam is being used in wet service conditions, $C_M = 0.9$ for $E$.
$C_t = 1$ as was discussed previously.
$C_i = 1$ as was discussed previously.
(Click on the blue down arrow to see the calculation for $E'$.)
beam.E_latex
The deflection equation for a beam subject to a uniformly distributed line load is, $$\text{Deflection} = \Delta = \frac{5 \times \text{Line Load} \times \text{(Span Length)}^4}{384 \times \text{Allowable Young's Modulus} \times \text{Moment of Inertia}}$$
or just,
$$\Delta = \frac{5 \times w \times L^4}{384 \times E' \times I}$$The equation can also be found on page 4 of the BEAM DESIGN FORMULAS WITH SHEAR AND MOMENT DIAGRAMS, a free pdf download from the American Wood Council.
Because the units of $E'$ is in $psi$, $I$ is in $in^4$, $w$ is in $plf$, $L$ is in $ft$ and we want $\Delta$ to come out inches, we need to apply a unit conversion factor.
Let's work one out.
(Click the blue down arrow to see the calculations for the unit conversion factor)
The unit of deflection are going to be in inches.
$$in=\frac{5 \times plf \times ft^4}{384 \times psi \times in^4}$$The constants don't mater to the units,
$$in=\frac{plf \times ft^4}{psi \times in^4} = \frac{\frac{lb}{ft} \times ft \times ft^3}{\frac{lb}{in^2} \times in^4}$$$$in=\frac{lb \times ft^3}{lb \times in^2} = \frac{ft^3}{in^2}$$So we need to convert $ft^3$ to $in^3$.
$$in=\frac{ft \times ft \times ft}{in^2} \times \frac{12 in}{1 ft}\times \frac{12 in}{1 ft}\times \frac{12 in}{1 ft}$$or
$$in=\frac{ft \times ft \times ft}{in^2} \times \left(\frac{12 in}{1 ft}\right)^3$$The value for the line load $(w)$ in the deflection equation for the Live Load is $w_{live} = 100plf$.
beam.deflect_simple_latex
(Click the blue down arrow to see the allowable Live Load deflections.)
Since the Allowable deflection for Live load only is $\frac{L}{360}$ for a floor member,
beam.deflect_allow(1/360)
$\Delta_{allowed} = 0.35" \geq \Delta_{live} = 0.256\text{"}$ $\text{the beam is GOOD for Live Load Deflection.}$
The value for the line load $(w)$ in the deflection equation for the Total Load is $w = 120plf$.
beam.deflect_simple_latex
(Click the blue down arrow to see the allowable Total Load deflections.)
Since the Allowable deflection for Total load is $\frac{L}{240}$ for a floor member,
beam.deflect_allow(1/240)
$\Delta_{allowed} = 0.525" \geq \Delta_{total} = 0.307\text{"}$ $\text{the beam is GOOD for Total Load Deflection.}$
An analysis of a 2x10 Douglas Fir-South Grade No.2 beam, used as a floor joist with a span of 10'-6", spaced 16" on center, in wet service conditions, with a Live Load deflection limit of L/360 and a Total Load deflection limit of L/240, yields these results.
$F_b' = 1344 psi \geq f_b = 928 psi \text{ so this beam is GOOD in bending.}$
$F_v' = 218 psi \geq f_v = 68 psi \text{ so this beam is GOOD in shear.}$
$\Delta_{\text{live allowed}} = 0.35" \geq \Delta_{live} = 0.256\text{" }$ $\text{the beam is GOOD for Live Load Deflection.}$
$\Delta_{\text{total allowed}} = 0.525" \geq \Delta_{total} = 0.307\text{" }$ $\text{the beam is GOOD for Total Load Deflection.}$
Therefore this beam is adequate for these loading conditions.
Class website (Use this link to if you are taking the course on e-learning.)
Github.io version of course website (Do not use this link if you are taking this course in Summer A or B.)
IPython.org (IPython is the opensource software used in the development of much of this course.)